Marc,
Let's hope that neither the Hy6/AFi or the S2 are 'dead ends'! When I had my DMR, I never thought Leica would kill the R system. Great camera as I'm sure the S2 is, however I'm still a bit put off from buying into another leica system since I don't trust they'll be kind. Stop and look at it - do you know for sure Leica will update the S2 with a new sensor or complete the lens line up? Probably as good a chance that someone will provide an updated back for the Hy6 in the future (we just got the AFi-ii 12 last year which is still available). Still the Hy6 path lets you default back to film and there's a plethora of legacy lenses available.
Eric
Reasonable observations and questions Eric.
I was lured to the S2 right from the start, but did not buy into it for over a year. Two Lenses wasn't a system, and the camera still needed work. Now it is 5 lenses, adapters for some interesting optics like the new Schneider 120 T/S, and firmware has significantly improved the camera's performance. The S2 is a focal plane camera so there are a vast selection of adaptable lenses available ... which I have zero interest in. Been there, done that.
I actually do not care if Leica ever upgrades the S2 sensor. Larger sensor 40 meg is a sweet spot for use hand held as well as studio tripod work. I only desire one more lens to add to the four I have ... and that is the next one in the lens line-up slotted for release in 2012 ... a S-24/2.8 ASPH. There are some who would like a focal length longer than the current 180 (longer is also planned), I am not one of them.
I don't think the R and S2 are the same scenario. The R had its multi-decade run ... all of the lenses are manual focus, and a digital R10 would competing with Canikony. A R10 would have looked to the past, instead Leica invented their own future. The DMR was excellent, but for that type of work, the Nikon D3X system killed it. On the other hand, there is nothing quite like the S2, and most certainly no lenses like the S optics.
At least that is my take on it ... whether it is justification or not, the same opinion as others or not ... is not at issue for me. I made the decision, and do not regret it at all. No buyers remorse what-so-ever. Been a long time since that happened
It is conceivable that as I move forward in the coming year(s), the S2 and M9/10 will be the only tools I choose to work with.
We'll see.
Anyway
... Happy New Year!
-Marc