same image:k5 and MF -which is which

[Paratom]

just for fun and I know that it doesnt say much at this size:
one with Hy6+80mm Schneider and Sinar back and one with K5 and 35mm limited- so which is which?

 

[Amin]

I'm guessing Pentax is the second one, because that one has more DOF. If you shot both lenses wide open with the same framing, the DOF would be similar.

 

[Paratom]

I'm guessing Pentax is the second one, because that one has more DOF. If you shot both lenses wide open with the same framing, the DOF would be similar.

I didnt say I shot at same f-stop

 

[ptomsu]

Pentax is second one

 

[Terry]

Sinar is the second

 

[Paratom]

by the way-the images on the internet look clearly worse than what I saw on my computer (worse tonal graduation). Dont know why.

 

[MGrayson]

That's reassuring. The second pic's skin tone and colors looks more lifelike on my mediocre screen, while the bokeh is better on the first pic, having shallower DoF.

Matt

 

[Schmiddi]

Hy6 is first - just from bokeh at first look (also have this lens and love this look).

Andreas

 

[Paratom]

ok, yes, Hy6 the first one and I did use f2.8 for both. So shallower DOF (and smoother bokeh?) might have been one of the points which helped to find out which is which.

 

[Terry]

The DOF bit was my initial reaction as soon as I saw. The fall off in DOF in the first is quite nice. Then I saw your message about not stating they were the same aperture. I then went back and tried to look at little details like the eyes and color. Interesting that that yellow in the bowl is more saturated in the first shot. I like the first shot except I'm not wild about the pink it is picking up on the right wall where it is OOF.

 

[Amin]

Based on the difference in DOF, it looked to me like you either shot both at the same f-number or you stopped the Schneider down by about 4 stops relative to the DA 35. The former seemed more likely to me; hence my guess .

 

[Paratom]

Based on the difference in DOF, it looked to me like you either shot both at the same f-number or you stopped the Schneider down by about 4 stops relative to the DA 35. The former seemed more likely to me; hence my guess .

yes, you were totally right I just wanted to add some confusion