Hi Jeff,
Guess I am late to this thread but you have been given some excellent advice with regards to Pentax 645 lenses. Early on with the advent of the release of the 645 D, I tested multiple samples of virtually all Pentax 645 AF lenses with that body and posted my comprehensive results here on Getdpi.
Subsequently in a part 2 of my lens testing, some time after my initial testing and posting of results, I tested the remaining newly released weather resitant lenses (25mm, 28-45, 90mm) as well as the manual focus 600 f5.6 with at least two samples of each of these. Finially with a borrowed 645z, I went back and tested many of these lenses. Of course the rendering of the two cameras were different but the results were essentually the same. A so-so sample in the corners with say a FA 35mm f3.5 on the 645D was still medicore when tested on a 645z.
I've been so consumed with work and other things that I never got around to posting these more recent results but have gladly provided my observations if asked. As others aptly pointed out, there is generally a marked improvement of performance with the new lenses and far less sample to same variability sans the 55 f2.8 and 25mm f4...the earlest two of this new grouping. Saes of both did vary in optical performance by auite a bit and others bore this out.
With regards to variability in lens samples, its very subjective from user to user. It greatly depends how one examines and uses their files and their personal expectations. I can only speak for myself but in testing I examined each file at actual pixels, corner to corner and also in crops of what would be equivelent to very sizeable large format prints since that is what was required for my particular use and needs.
Once again I don't have the link to the page on Getdpi where my comprehensive Pentax 645 lens test is posted but others here have always kindly provided it.
As for W&G, they are helarious and I would love if someone would post a simple list of all their (W&G's) available DVD's for purchase.
Thanks everyone!
Dave (D&A)
Guess I am late to this thread but you have been given some excellent advice with regards to Pentax 645 lenses. Early on with the advent of the release of the 645 D, I tested multiple samples of virtually all Pentax 645 AF lenses with that body and posted my comprehensive results here on Getdpi.
Subsequently in a part 2 of my lens testing, some time after my initial testing and posting of results, I tested the remaining newly released weather resitant lenses (25mm, 28-45, 90mm) as well as the manual focus 600 f5.6 with at least two samples of each of these. Finially with a borrowed 645z, I went back and tested many of these lenses. Of course the rendering of the two cameras were different but the results were essentually the same. A so-so sample in the corners with say a FA 35mm f3.5 on the 645D was still medicore when tested on a 645z.
I've been so consumed with work and other things that I never got around to posting these more recent results but have gladly provided my observations if asked. As others aptly pointed out, there is generally a marked improvement of performance with the new lenses and far less sample to same variability sans the 55 f2.8 and 25mm f4...the earlest two of this new grouping. Saes of both did vary in optical performance by auite a bit and others bore this out.
With regards to variability in lens samples, its very subjective from user to user. It greatly depends how one examines and uses their files and their personal expectations. I can only speak for myself but in testing I examined each file at actual pixels, corner to corner and also in crops of what would be equivelent to very sizeable large format prints since that is what was required for my particular use and needs.
Once again I don't have the link to the page on Getdpi where my comprehensive Pentax 645 lens test is posted but others here have always kindly provided it.
As for W&G, they are helarious and I would love if someone would post a simple list of all their (W&G's) available DVD's for purchase.
Thanks everyone!
Dave (D&A)