The GetDPI Photography Forum

Great to see you here. Join our insightful photographic forum today and start tapping into a huge wealth of photographic knowledge. Completing our simple registration process will allow you to gain access to exclusive content, add your own topics and posts, share your work and connect with other members through your own private inbox! And don’t forget to say hi!

Fun with MF Achromatic Digital Backs

ThdeDude

Well-known member
I wrote a long posting, but then, on second thought, this thread is not really a print review/critic and any nonpositive comments, as well intended, may be unwelcome.
 

Greg Haag

Well-known member
i think nonpositive comments are welcome as long as they are not insulting, i for one would prefer a comment about what people like or dislike about my images rather than just a like

constructive criticism i absolutely ok imho
My general thoughts would be if someone asks for constructive criticism, then cordial constructive criticism is appropriate. If someone does not ask for it then a simply like or don't like, whichever is appropriate. I think for some it is a big step to start posting images on the forum and we should be careful about things that discourage future postings. My general policy is if I have to ask myself if one of my potential comments is appropriate then I don't post it, I have failed on this from time to time and always regret it when I do. I am grateful for an active forum and hope to see it continue to flourish.
 

ThdeDude

Well-known member
My general thoughts would be if someone asks for constructive criticism, then cordial constructive criticism is appropriate. If someone does not ask for it then a simply like or don't like, whichever is appropriate. I think for some it is a big step to start posting images on the forum and we should be careful about things that discourage future postings. My general policy is if I have to ask myself if one of my potential comments is appropriate then I don't post it, I have failed on this from time to time and always regret it when I do. I am grateful for an active forum and hope to see it continue to flourish.
My general feeling also. Glad that I did not post what I wrote initially.

I will start a thread titled - Print Review/Critic/Idea - with some suggested rules & guidelines as to comments. Whoever posts images in that thread knows what to expect.

I have participated in dozens of print reviews at workshops and my general feeling is that good, constructive feedback from numerous, well-informed parties can be very useful to a receptive photographer. Also the other way round; I found discussing strength and shortcomings of someone else's images helps me to train my photographic eye.
Dunning-Kruger Effect does apply to photography and getting out of the trough isn't easy.
 
Last edited:

ThdeDude

Well-known member
I am contemplating exchanging the UV/IF filter on my P1 DB for a neutral filter, in other words, undergo a "full color conversion". I intend to use various filters, for example, "Standard IR" 720nm, "Super Color IF" 590nm, and "real color" UV/IF filter. (Using LifePixel's terminology here.)

Rudolf Arnheim wrote in Art and Visual Perception that:

"Van Gogh thought of expressing the moods of the four seasons through four pairs: red and green (the apple blossoms and young corn of spring) , blue and orange (the summer sky and the golden bronze of the ripe grain), yellow and violet (the autumn leaves), and the black and white of winter."

Having the various filters I will try to follow Van Gogh's use of color. For example, for an autumn motif yellow & violet, or a summer motif red & green. (But this will not be exclusive, will also keep taking "real" color and B&W photographs.)

Any thoughts or suggestions?

(Please no hesitation; like to hear critical comments why this won't work, why a stupid idea, insult to Van Gogh, etc.)
 
Last edited:

tcdeveau

Well-known member
It’s a great idea to breath some new life into gear that you’ve got sitting on the shelf.

I had life pixel do a full spectrum conversion on an A7R once and had a lot of fun with it.

definitely having a lot of fun with the IQ4 150A and it’s lack of UV/IR.

the only drawbacks, IMHO, are all the filters you have to carry around (it’s part of the fun but it can get annoying), and if you ever look to sell in the future, converted cameras can sometimes be harder to move than unconverted.
 

cunim

Well-known member
@lookbook, this picture depresses me. All those years of anonymous hotel rooms come flooding back.

A photo that triggers an emotional reaction is fine work
 

lookbook

Well-known member
@lookbook, this picture depresses me. All those years of anonymous hotel rooms come flooding back.

A photo that triggers an emotional reaction is fine work
... I like very much that you express your feelings in what kind moves you the photo.
Your statement shows me once again how different the reactions, even opposite the reactions to a picture can be.
Each viewer is picked up by a picture at the stop, at which he just stands.

Thank you very much ...
 

drevil

Well-known member
Staff member


i finished my second tour exploring the swiss alps today, it was another long drive of like 8 hours and 400km, as basel is still 1-2 hours away from the serious mountains.
this time i went up to 2400m, and i saw many incredible sights.

contax 645, 35mm distagon and phase one achromatic+ with haida 720nm IR filter
 

JeffK

Well-known member
I previously posted the BTS of this last week when I was at Dinosaur Provincial Park in Alberta, Canada. Here's the results from that.

ALPA STC
IQ3 100 Achromatic
70mm Alpagon / Yellow filter

DinosaurProvPark-Alberta.jpg

IMG_9501.jpeg
 
Last edited:

tcdeveau

Well-known member
I previously posted the BTS of this last week when I was at Dinosaur Provincial Park in Alberta, Canada. Here's the results from that.

ALPA STC
IQ3 100 Achromatic
70mm Alpagon / Yellow filter

View attachment 205954

View attachment 205955
Yep those hills look like they're made of real dinosaur alright. Nice shot! Would love to visit there some day, I think we have a dinosaur NP on this side of the border too.
 
Top