Hello all, I was wondering if anybody had information or experience with using the new sinar econtrol (doesn't need the external interface box) in getting it to sync, wake up signal and all, with phase one backs. It would be a great addition to those of us using technical cameras with long exposures and stitching. I know of the Alpa Silex but the sinar is half the price with a simpler interface, hotshoe, app control and better mounting options at tripod level.
https://sinar.swiss/products/lenses/sinaron-digital-en-us/sinaron-digital-en-us-2/
We sell both Sinar and Alpa products and we have clients who are using both solutions and with Phase One digital backs. There are distinct differences. They do share the ability to wake up Phase One backs. They do provide electronic control over lenses outfitted in eShutter 125 and eShutter 250. They each have some additional functionality (extended bracketing, self-timer, etc.).
I think it is fair to say that if all one is after is to use eShutter lenses and have some modest functionality along with that, then the Sinar solution works well. And if one is studio bound, you can save nearly $1,000 by using the Sinar "Box" eShutter Controller instead of the portable unit.
Where the Alpa Silex extends is with more advanced functionality, some of the functions are similar, but can be extended further, or have some nuances that allow for some differing workflows. The Silex also is a platform for numerous other type of lenses, when combined with Alpa cameras and the appropriate lensboards, or Phase One digital backs with Electronic Shutter capability (similar to FPS).
It's nice to have a hot shoe on the Sinar unit. The Silex does have quarter inch sockets on bottom and side, so there are ample routes for tripod mounting.
Differences in price are below with List pricing for each. The portable Sinar is not quite half the price, but certainly less. I think the 2 products complement each other well, depending on someone's budget and functional needs.
$1,742 - Sinar "Box" eShutter Control Unit
$2,710 - Sinar "Portable" eControl Unit
$3,660 - Alpa Silex I (not compatible with eShutter lenses)
$4,250 - Alpa Silex II is $4,250.
Steve Hendrix/CI