Streetshooter
Subscriber Member
Jack,
Of course I have to go against the grain on this one....here's why...
In the B&W version, the shapes are FLAT...not tonally but dimensionally.
There is almost no eye travel....
The color version sports good eye travel because the red of the bag repeats against the background signs and more importantly against the (Irritant) the shape on his hat.
The shape on the top of the rolled bag has a similar shape to the mans head and shoulder....in the B&W, this shape competes too much to the point of neutrality....
Because of the primary colors.....he is separated nicely from the background....
Notice the B&W version is flat...not tonally again but dimensionally.....
Well, that's about it.....I am a B&W shooter almost 99 1/2% of the time but sometimes Mother Color has a sense of humor......
Shooter
Of course I have to go against the grain on this one....here's why...
In the B&W version, the shapes are FLAT...not tonally but dimensionally.
There is almost no eye travel....
The color version sports good eye travel because the red of the bag repeats against the background signs and more importantly against the (Irritant) the shape on his hat.
The shape on the top of the rolled bag has a similar shape to the mans head and shoulder....in the B&W, this shape competes too much to the point of neutrality....
Because of the primary colors.....he is separated nicely from the background....
Notice the B&W version is flat...not tonally again but dimensionally.....
Well, that's about it.....I am a B&W shooter almost 99 1/2% of the time but sometimes Mother Color has a sense of humor......
Shooter