ErikKaffehr
Well-known member
Hi Graham,
Lets just say that they are very natural colours. And those petals were definitively not blue…
The reason I took this is that I had a discussion with the publisher of OnLandscape, a British Journal, who stated that the P45+ was not capable of correct reproduction of green vegetation, while I sort of believed it could be more of a colour profile issue.
The interesting thing here is that Capture One reproduces the colour as blue, both on P45+ and A99, while Adobe actually does a good job on both.
The Colour Munki Colour picker picked the petal sample as "deep bluish purple" on the pantone palette. Using the color picker in Photoshop CS it picked the very same Pantone colour on the A99/LR conversion, so that repro was quite good.
I don't understand your statement: "Lets see a more neutral comparison without full spectrum influence.", you mean that back/software is not expected to handle full spectrum?
Best regards
Erik
Lets just say that they are very natural colours. And those petals were definitively not blue…
The reason I took this is that I had a discussion with the publisher of OnLandscape, a British Journal, who stated that the P45+ was not capable of correct reproduction of green vegetation, while I sort of believed it could be more of a colour profile issue.
The interesting thing here is that Capture One reproduces the colour as blue, both on P45+ and A99, while Adobe actually does a good job on both.
The Colour Munki Colour picker picked the petal sample as "deep bluish purple" on the pantone palette. Using the color picker in Photoshop CS it picked the very same Pantone colour on the A99/LR conversion, so that repro was quite good.
I don't understand your statement: "Lets see a more neutral comparison without full spectrum influence.", you mean that back/software is not expected to handle full spectrum?
Best regards
Erik
Erik
now you know that you are guilty of picking THE worst color to check with a spectrometer vs the eye.
Bluebells or the flowers you showed typically do not photograph well due to UV/IR and what you show are the classic blue vs purple/pink rendering that technically 'correct' rendering vs what the eye sees. I have hundreds of images of pink/purple bell flowers that only a specific qualitative filter/rendering presented as the correct color that I saw. I see the same thing happening with the C1 rendering vs adobe.
Lets see a more neutral comparison without full spectrum influence.